
Early releases for September 8, 2011 (about CUAJ early releases)
Cancer Care Ontario Guidelines for radical prostatectomy: striving for continuous quality improvement in community practice
Todd M. Webster, Christopher Newell; John F. Amrhein, Ken J. Newell
Abstract
Effectiveness of medical treatment in overcoming the ureteral double-J stent related symptoms
Ugur Kuyumcuoglu, Bilal Eryildirim, Murat Tuncer, Gokhan Faydaci, Fatih Tarhan, Aydin Ozgül
Abstract
Diagnosis and prognosis of malignant mesothelioma of the tunica
vaginalis testis
Bo Hai, Yu Yang, Yajun Xiao, Bing Li, Chaohui Chen
Abstract
Reproductibilité des classifications OMS 1973 et OMS 2004 des tumeurs urothéliales papillaires de la vessie
Soumaya Ben Abdelkrim, Soumaya Rammeh, Amel Trabelsi, Lilia Ben Yacoub-Abid, Nabil Ben Sorba, Lilia Jaïdane, Moncef Mokni
Abstract
Cancer Care Ontario Guidelines for radical prostatectomy: striving for continuous quality improvement in community practice
Abstract
Objective: Cancer Care Ontario has published an evidence-based guideline on their website “Guideline for Optimization of Surgical and Pathological Quality Performance for Radical Prostatectomy in Prostate Cancer Management: Surgical and Pathological Guidelines.” The evidentiary base for this guideline was recently published in CUAJ. The CCO guideline proposes the following: a positive surgical margin (PSM) rate of <25% for organ-confined disease (pT2), a perioperative mortality of <1%, a rate of rectal injury <1%, and a blood transfusion rate <10% in non-anemic patients. The objective of this study was to review the radical prostatectomy practice at the Grey Bruce Health Services, an Ontario community hospital, and to compare our performance in relation to the Cancer Care Ontario guideline and the literature.
Methods: We conducted a retrospective review of all radical prostatectomies performed at the Grey Bruce Health Services from
January 1, 2006 to December 31, 2007. The following data were
obtained from clinical records and pathology reports: patient age,
pre-biopsy prostate-specific antigen, biopsy Gleason score, resected
prostate gland weight, radical prostatectomy Gleason score,
surgical margin status, pathological tumour stage (pT), lymph node
dissection status, perioperative incidence of transfusion of blood
products and if the patient was anemic (hemoglobin <140 g/L) preoperatively, incidence of rectal injury, and perioperative mortality
within 30 days following surgery.
Results: Using the method proposed by D’Amico, most patients
undergoing radical prostatectomy were intermediate risk (62%),
with a minority of low-risk (24%) and high-risk (14%) patients. The
overall PSM rate was 37%. The rate of PSMs in organ-confined
disease (pT2) was 26%. There was a statistically significant trend
between increasing D’Amico risk category and increasing rate of
PSM (Cochran-Armitage trend test, p = 0.023). There was a strong
correlation between the pathological tumour stage and the rate of
PSM (Cochran-Armitage trend test, p = 0.0003). The rate of blood
transfusion in non-anemic patients was 6%. There was 1 patient
(0.8%) who experienced a rectal injury. There were no perioperative
deaths in our study group.
Conclusion: Our results show that a community hospital group
can appropriately select patients to undergo radical prostatectomy,
as well as achieve an acceptable rate of PSMs. We believe that
ongoing critical appraisal and reflective practice are essential to
improving surgical outcomes and providing quality care.
Effectiveness of medical treatment in overcoming the ureteral double-J stent related symptoms
Abstract
Background: We investigated whether the frequency of lower urinary
tract symptoms (LUTS) increased in patients in whom double-J
stents were applied. We also evaluated several medical therapy
protocols to treat symptoms related with ureteral stents.
Materials and Methods: A total of 108 patients, in whom unilateral
double-j stent was applied during ureteral stone treatment, were
included. Before the double-J stent was applied, all patients completed
storage components of the “International Prostate Symptom
Score” (IPSSs), quality of life components of the IPSS (IPSS-QOL)
and “Overactive Bladder Questionnaire” (OABq) forms and scores
were calculated. After the procedure, cases were randomized into
5 groups, an antiinflammatory was given to Group 1, spasmolytic
to Group 2, anticholinergic to Group 3 and a-blocker to Group
4. No additional drug was given to Group 5 as this control group.
During the fourth week of the procedure, IPSSs, IPSS-QOL and
OABq forms were again completed and scores were compared
with the previous ones.
Results: When all the cases were evaluated, the IPSSs, IPSS-QOL
and OABq scores of patients in whom the double-J stent was applied
were statistically significantly higher the procedure. Compared
to the control group, the cases where the double-J stent was applied
showed a higher IPSSs, IPSS-QOL and OABq scores and none of
the medical therapies could prevent this increase.
Interpretation: The frequency of LUTS increased in cases where
the ureteral stent was applied and discomfort continued as long
as the stent stayed in the body.
Diagnosis and prognosis of malignant mesothelioma of the tunica
vaginalis testis
Abstract
Objectives: The objective of this study is to evaluate the diagnosis
and prognosis of malignant mesothelioma of the tunica vaginalis
testis through an additional 6 patients with urogenital mesothelioma.
Methods: Six patients with urogenital mesothelioma who underwent
adequate surgical procedures and histopathologic analysis
from 1990 to 2009 were identified and retrospectively reviewed.
Results: Six patients between the ages of 26 and 78 years with
urogenital mesothelioma, 5 of which originated in the scrotum
and 1 in the spermatic cord. Histopathologic analysis showed that
CK5/6 and calretinin were positive in all cases, 5 cases were positive
for vimentin, and 1 case showed focal weak positive reaction
with MOC3, but none of the cases stained for CEA or CD15. The
overall recurrence rate of urogenital mesothelioma after surgery
was 5/6, including local recurrences and fatalities due to tumour.
Conclusions: In cases of mesothelioma of the tunica vaginalis testis,
the histopathologic markers we chose helped con?rm the histopathological
diagnosis; adequate surgical procedures are typically
not curative, and this tumour is often fatal.
Reproductibilité des classifications OMS 1973 et OMS 2004 des tumeurs urothéliales papillaires de la vessie
Résumé
Objectif : Déterminer les taux d’accord et la reproductibilité intra
et inter-observateurs des classifications OMS 1973 et OMS 2004
des tumeurs urothéliales papillaires de la vessie.
Matériel et méthodes : Cent deux cas de tumeurs urothéliales
papillaires de stade pTa/pT1 ont été étudiés. Deux pathologistes ont
revu les lames et ont établi le grade tumoral selon les deux classifications
OMS 1973 et OMS 2004. En cas de désaccord, les deux
évaluateurs ont procédé à une lecture commune au microscope
en double tête afin d’aboutir à un grade consensuel selon les deux
classifications. La variabilité intra-observateur a été étudiée chez
l’un des deux évaluateurs qui a procédé à la relecture des lames
un mois après sa première lecture. Les taux d’accord entre les deux
pathologistes pour chaque catégorie de grade ont été déterminés et
la reproductibilité des deux classifications a été évaluée à l’aide du
coefficient kappa. Une valeur de 0 à 0,2 était interprétée comme
un désaccord absolu, de 0,21 à 0,4, un accord faible, de 0,41 à
0,6, un accord modéré, de 0,61 à 0,8, un accord considérable, et
de 0,8 à 1, un accord absolu.
Résultats : Selon la classification OMS 1973, les proportions des
grades G1, G2 et G3 étaient respectivement de 40,2 %, 50 % et
9,8 %. Selon la classification OMS 2004, les proportions respectives
des tumeurs de faible potentiel de malignité, des carcinomes
de bas grade et des carcinomes de haut grade de malignité étaient
de 23,5 %, 60,8 % et 15,7 %. La reproductibilité intra-observateur
était excellente pour les deux classifications (accord absolu). Les
taux d’accord entre les deux pathologistes étaient meilleurs pour
la classification OMS 2004 (kappa = 0,7) que pour la classification
OMS 1973 (kappa = 0,51).
Conclusions : La reproductibilité entre observateurs de la classification
OMS 2004 est supérieure à celle de 1973. La reproductibilité
intra-observateur est excellente pour les deux classifications.
CUAJ has adopted an early release model, in which papers are published online in advance of their print publication. The print publication schedule remains the same: February, April, June, August, October, December; however, CUAJ is now posting new early release articles on its website (www.cuaj.ca) every other month (January, March, May, July, September, November). CUAJ early releases articles only apply to research articles.
These early release articles are peer-reviewed, accepted, edited and formatting just like print articles, except for the fact that they are released online before they are published in print and do not have a volume/issue/page number. Only the digital object identifier (DOI) is used as an identifier for the article (i.e., DOI:10.5489/cuaj.09116). The "DOI:10.5489" is the journal identifier and the "cuaj.09116" is the identifier associated with a particular article. Each CUAJ article carries a DOI, which serves as its unique electronic identification tag. As soon as an article is published in a print issue, it will be assigned a page number and transferred to that issue's table of contents on the website. The DOI remains attached to the paper to provide a persistent identifier.
For convenience, the PDF version of every early release article is given a temporary pagination, with each article beginning on page 1. This pagination, however, is unrelated to the final pagination of the print article and should not be used for citation purposes.
The CUAJ Editorial Board strongly believes that rapid online publication is a valuable service to readers and authors, and we encourage you to visit the CUAJ website often at www.cuaj.ca.